Your 2004 Cadillac XLRproblems, repair costs and recalls
What we've documented about the 2004 Cadillac XLR: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.
Ownership snapshot
Averages, not quotesRoutine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.
Known problems for your 2004 Cadillac XLR
27 documented issues apply to 2004, most serious first.
Retractable hardtop stops partway or won't move
- What you'll notice
- The power hardtop stalls halfway, won't start to open or close, or you hear the pump running while the roof doesn't move. The trunk may open but the roof never follows.
- Why it happens
- The roof relies on several position sensors, a control module and a hydraulic pump. A sensor that reads wrong, low hydraulic fluid or a leaking cylinder stops the sequence as a safety measure.
- What to do
- Don't force the roof by hand. Check that the trunk is fully closed and the cargo divider is in place, then have a shop that knows XLRs scan the roof module and check sensor readings and pump fluid.
Roof panel separates from the frame
- What you'll notice
- The front roof panel lifts, flutters or comes completely off the frame, usually at highway speed.
- Why it happens
- The outer roof skin is bonded to its frame with adhesive. On some cars the bond lets go over time. GM collected field data on this roof skin separation in 2019.
- What to do
- If you see a gap at the roof edge, a lifting skin or hear wind noise from the top, stop driving at speed and have the bond inspected right away. A loose panel can strike cars behind you.
Gasoline smell or fuel leak from the tank lines
- What you'll notice
- Strong raw-gas smell around the car or in the garage, wet spots under the rear, or a check engine light for an evaporative leak.
- Why it happens
- The XLR uses two linked fuel tanks. Owners report leaks at the crossover pipe, the feed lines and the pump connection, and GM ran a service campaign for leaks at the tank's quick connectors.
- What to do
- Treat any fuel smell as urgent: park outside and have the tank lines inspected. Ask a Cadillac dealer with your VIN whether the quick-connector campaign was done.
Shift cable breaks so the car won't shift or stays in gear
- What you'll notice
- The shifter moves but the car stays in Park, or it moves in a different gear than the shifter shows. Some owners had the car roll or move in reverse unexpectedly.
- Why it happens
- The cable that connects the shifter to the rear-mounted transmission can fray and snap with age.
- What to do
- Stop driving and set the parking brake if the shifter feels loose or the gear doesn't match. Have the shift cable replaced before using the car.
Rear brake lines can overheat from the exhaust (recall)
- What you'll notice
- A soft or sinking brake pedal, longer stops, or brake fluid leaking at the rear.
- Why it happens
- The rear brake lines can sit too close to the left exhaust and get hot enough to boil the brake fluid or wear through.
- What to do
- Have a dealer confirm recall 04V525000 was done. They check clearance, reroute the lines and replace any that are worn.
Lower control arm ball joint nut can loosen (recall)
- What you'll notice
- A clunk from a corner of the car, the car pulling to one side, or a wheel tilted outward.
- Why it happens
- The washer under the ball joint nut was made of the wrong steel and can crack, so the nut loses clamp and the control arm can separate from the knuckle.
- What to do
- Make sure recall 04V273000 was done. If you hear clunks, stop and have the suspension checked.
StabiliTrak brakes a wheel or the rear steps out unexpectedly
- What you'll notice
- The stability control kicks in on its own, one wheel brakes, the rear of the car slides, or you see 'Service StabiliTrak' messages.
- Why it happens
- Owners report the stability system acting without a reason, which points to a faulty wheel speed, steering angle or yaw sensor, or a wiring fault.
- What to do
- Have the stability and ABS codes read and the sensors tested. Drive gently until it is diagnosed, especially in the wet.
Hydraulic fluid leak from the roof cylinders or lines
- What you'll notice
- Oily fluid in the trunk or roof storage area, and the roof moves slowly or stops working.
- Why it happens
- GM issued bulletins for fluid seeping from the roof's hydraulic cylinders and for roof hydraulic lines that rub through at the right rear.
- What to do
- Have the cylinders and lines checked for wetness. Fixing a leak early saves the pump from running dry.
Fuel gauge reads wrong or drops to empty
- What you'll notice
- The fuel gauge jumps around, reads half full after you fill up, or reads empty with fuel still in the tank. Some cars can run out of fuel with the gauge near half.
- Why it happens
- The fuel level sensors in the twin tanks give bad readings. GM put out bulletins and revised sender values for the Corvette and XLR.
- What to do
- Track miles since your last fill-up until it is fixed. A shop can check the sender readings and update or replace the level sensor.
Engine oil leaks from the Northstar V8
- What you'll notice
- Oil spots under the car, a burning oil smell after driving, or oil wetness at the front or bottom of the engine.
- Why it happens
- The Northstar V8 is known for seeping at the lower crankcase seal, oil pan gasket and front cover. GM issued several bulletins for oil leaks at the front, rear and crankcase on the XLR engine.
- What to do
- Check the oil level often and have the leak traced. Small seeps can be watched, but leaks onto the exhaust are a fire risk and should be fixed.
Headlights or running lights melt, fog up or fail
- What you'll notice
- Headlight or daytime running light lenses look melted, cloudy or full of moisture, or lamps stop working.
- Why it happens
- Heat and water get into the lamp housings. GM issued bulletins for water in the headlamps, and owners report melted running light lenses. New replacement lamps are hard to find now.
- What to do
- Have the lamps checked before an inspection. Used or rebuilt assemblies are often the only option, so shop around.
Turn signal and running light bulb burns out early (recall)
- What you'll notice
- The turn signal indicator on the dash flashes faster than normal, or the front turn signal or running light is out.
- Why it happens
- One bulb does the job of running light, turn signal and parking lamp. A loose socket or a poor seal makes it burn out early.
- What to do
- Ask a Cadillac dealer to check your VIN for recall 06V263000. They replace both sockets and bulbs for free.
Engine may not return to idle in extreme cold (recall)
- What you'll notice
- In very cold weather the engine may be slow to drop back to idle after you lift off the gas, so stopping takes more brake effort.
- Why it happens
- The accelerator pedal has two return springs. If one breaks at about -22°F or colder, the pedal may not return quickly enough to meet the federal standard.
- What to do
- Check that recall 05V046000 was done. The dealer replaces the accelerator pedal assembly.
Cracked or broken composite leaf spring
- What you'll notice
- A clunk or bang over bumps, the car sitting lower on one corner or end, or harsh, uneven ride.
- Why it happens
- Like the Corvette, the XLR uses plastic composite leaf springs across the car. GM issued a bulletin for front and rear composite springs that crack or break on 2004–2009 XLRs.
- What to do
- Have the springs inspected on a lift. A broken spring changes ride height and handling, so replace it before driving hard.
Leaking shocks or 'Service Suspension' warning
- What you'll notice
- A 'Service Suspension System' message, a bouncy or harsh ride, or oil wetness on a shock.
- Why it happens
- The Magnetic Ride shocks can leak with age, and GM issued a bulletin for the shock wiring connectors not being fully seated.
- What to do
- Have the suspension codes read and the connectors checked first, since that is the cheap fix. Magnetic shocks are expensive, so confirm a leak before replacing one.
Run-flat tires wear fast, bubble or are costly to replace
- What you'll notice
- A bulge in the tire sidewall, fast wear, or a flat with no spare tire in the car. Replacement tires can take days to arrive.
- Why it happens
- The XLR comes with run-flat tires and no spare. Their stiff sidewalls can bubble after a pothole and they cost much more than normal tires.
- What to do
- Check tire pressure monthly and inspect sidewalls after hard hits. A sidewall bubble means the tire must be replaced.
Doors won't open with a dead battery or failed fob
- What you'll notice
- The electronic door buttons don't open the doors, or you can get stuck inside or outside the car when the battery is weak.
- Why it happens
- The XLR uses electric door releases instead of normal handles. GM sent an advisory about the inside manual release for when the battery is low or the fob doesn't work.
- What to do
- Learn where the manual inside release is from your owner's manual. Replace a weak battery early and keep a spare fob battery.
No start from steering column lock fault
- What you'll notice
- The car won't start, or you get a steering column message, and the steering wheel may stay locked.
- Why it happens
- The electric steering column lock module can lose communication with the car, and GM issued a bulletin on this.
- What to do
- Have the column lock module codes read. Don't keep cranking; a dealer or specialist can test the module and wiring.
Water in the trunk or passenger footwell
- What you'll notice
- Wet carpet in the passenger footwell, water in the trunk well behind the roof, or electrical glitches after rain.
- Why it happens
- Roof drains can clog, letting water collect. GM also issued a bulletin on water leaking at the passenger floor near the body control module.
- What to do
- Check and clear the roof drains, especially the one by the driver-side trunk opening. Dry the carpet quickly so the module and wiring aren't damaged.
Shifter won't come out of Park at times
- What you'll notice
- You press the brake but the shift lever stays locked in Park.
- Why it happens
- GM published a bulletin for XLRs whose shift lever could not be moved out of Park at times.
- What to do
- Check that the brake lights work, since the shift lock uses the brake switch. A dealer can check the shift lock parts and any bulletin repair.
Front brakes squeal under light braking
- What you'll notice
- A squeal from the front when you press the brake pedal lightly.
- Why it happens
- GM issued bulletins for front brake squeal on the XLR during normal stops.
- What to do
- A shop can install updated pads or anti-noise parts. The noise alone is not a safety issue if the pads have plenty of material.
Driver door won't open from the outside touch pad
- What you'll notice
- The driver's door opens from inside but not from the outside touch pad.
- Why it happens
- GM issued a bulletin for the driver door touch pad not working from outside.
- What to do
- A dealer can check the touch pad switch and door module. Use the key fob or the inside release meanwhile.
Ratcheting or clicking noise on cold start
- What you'll notice
- A brief ratcheting or clicking sound from the engine right after a cold start.
- Why it happens
- GM issued a bulletin for this cold-start noise on the 4.6L Northstar.
- What to do
- If it goes away in seconds, it is usually harmless, but mention it at service so the dealer can check the bulletin.
Blue smoke at startup
- What you'll notice
- A puff of blue smoke from the exhaust right after starting, then it clears.
- Why it happens
- Oil seeps past the valve seals or rings while the car sits. GM issued a bulletin for this on the 4.6L Northstar in the XLR.
- What to do
- Watch your oil level. If smoke is heavy or the engine uses more than a quart every couple thousand miles, have it checked.
Rear axle chatter or clunk on turns
- What you'll notice
- A chatter, shudder or clunk from the rear when turning slowly, such as in parking lots.
- Why it happens
- The rear differential fluid breaks down. GM's bulletin calls for draining and refilling the differential with the correct fluid and additive.
- What to do
- Have the rear differential fluid changed. This usually stops the chatter.
Telescoping steering wheel won't adjust
- What you'll notice
- The power tilt or telescope steering column doesn't move when you use the switch.
- Why it happens
- GM issued a bulletin for the XLR telescoping steering wheel not working.
- What to do
- Have the column motor and switch checked. It's a comfort issue, not a safety one.
Power steering fluid leak at the pump hose
- What you'll notice
- Power steering fluid dripping near the front of the engine, whining when turning, or a low fluid level.
- Why it happens
- GM issued a bulletin for leaks at the high-pressure hose connection to the power steering pump.
- What to do
- Keep the reservoir topped up and have the hose connection resealed or the hose replaced.
Repair prices for your 2004 Cadillac XLR
Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.
- Diagnose roof system; replace a position sensor or service the hydraulic pump
- Re-bond or replace the front roof panel
- Replace leaking roof hydraulic cylinder or line and refill
- Replace fuel tank crossover pipe, feed line or connectors
- Replace fuel level sending unit
- Reseal lower crankcase and oil pan
- Replace transmission shift cable
- Diagnose and repair shift lock or brake switch
- Replace headlamp or running lamp assembly (one side)
- Replace front or rear composite leaf spring
- Reseat suspension connector or replace one Magnetic Ride shock
- Diagnose stability system; replace steering wheel position or wheel speed sensor
- Replace front brake pads with updated pads
- Replace one run-flat tire, mount and balance
- Replace 12V battery and test door release system
- Replace driver door touch pad switch or latch actuator
- Diagnose and replace steering column lock module
- Clear roof drains and reseal leak; dry carpet
- Diagnose cold-start noise per GM bulletin
- Diagnose oil consumption and valve seal leakage
- Drain and refill rear differential fluid with additive
- Repair or replace power steering column motor or switch
- Replace power steering pressure hose or seal
Recall repairs: usually free at the dealer
A dealer can confirm coverage by VIN. An eligible safety recall repair is provided at no charge.
- Replace lamp sockets and bulbsNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Reroute or replace rear brake linesNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Replace ball joint nut and washerNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Replace accelerator pedal assemblyNo charge if your vehicle is included
Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.
Checking the NHTSA recall database…