Your 2008 smart fortwoproblems, repair costs and recalls
What we've documented about the 2008 smart fortwo: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.
Ownership snapshot
Averages, not quotesRoutine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)
Ask for an estimate
The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.
Known problems for your 2008 smart fortwo
21 documented issues apply to 2008, most serious first.
Clutch actuator failure (car won't shift or move)
- What you'll notice
- The car suddenly won't select a gear, gets stuck in neutral or one gear, shows a transmission warning, or won't move from a stop. It may slip first, on and off, before failing completely.
- Why it happens
- This generation uses an automated manual gearbox: a regular clutch worked by an electric clutch actuator motor and a computer. The actuator motor and its shaft wear out or break, and corrosion from water can kill it.
- What to do
- Stop driving if it won't hold a gear. A shop that knows smart cars should test the actuator before replacing the clutch or the whole gearbox; a used or rebuilt actuator can save money.
Engine compartment fire risk from loose insulation mat (recall)
- What you'll notice
- A check engine light, smoke or a burning smell from the rear engine area. Fires reported to NHTSA spread quickly.
- Why it happens
- The insulation mat in the rear engine compartment can deform, break down and come loose, then touch hot exhaust parts. NHTSA had looked into reports of 2008-2009 fortwos catching fire; the fix is recall 18V-273.
- What to do
- Have a dealer check the VIN and install the improved mat for free. If you see smoke or smell burning, pull over, turn off the car and get out.
Windshield and roof bond paint defect (recall)
- What you'll notice
- No warning. In rare cases the paint where the windshield and roof are glued could let go while driving.
- Why it happens
- A batch of paint did not meet spec, and repainted areas could peel at the windshield and roof adhesive joint (recall 08V-390, a small number of early 2008 cars).
- What to do
- Have a dealer check the VIN to confirm the repaint was done.
Won't go into reverse or stuck in neutral
- What you'll notice
- Reverse sometimes won't engage, most often on the first start of the day or when warm. The display may show N with a warning beep, and the car can get stuck in neutral.
- Why it happens
- The transmission control software and the clutch adjustment are often to blame. Many owners were fixed with a software update and a resync of the shifter; others needed a new clutch plate.
- What to do
- Ask a dealer or smart specialist for the latest transmission software and a clutch relearn first. If that doesn't help, have the clutch plate and actuator checked.
Clutch slipping or worn clutch plate
- What you'll notice
- The engine revs up without the car speeding up, jerky or choppy shifts, or the car hesitates to move off.
- Why it happens
- The automated gearbox still uses a dry clutch plate that wears out, and the computer-controlled engagement can wear it faster. German breakdown data showed clutch problems peaking on 2008-2009 cars.
- What to do
- Have the clutch checked and the transmission software updated. If the plate is worn, replace it along with any damaged actuator parts.
Water leaks damaging transmission electronics
- What you'll notice
- Damp carpets or water in the cabin, followed by shifting faults or a car that won't select gears.
- Why it happens
- Water getting into the car can reach the transmission control unit and the clutch actuator, shorting or corroding them.
- What to do
- Find and seal the water leak first. Then have the transmission electronics and actuator checked for corrosion.
Engine misfire from failed ignition coils
- What you'll notice
- The engine shakes or runs rough, feels down on power, and the check engine light may flash.
- Why it happens
- The ignition coils on the 1.0L engine fail, and some owners have had to replace them more than once.
- What to do
- Have the misfire codes read. Replacing the bad coil (or all three) usually fixes it; avoid driving with a flashing check engine light.
Starter failure (click or no crank)
- What you'll notice
- You turn the key and hear a click or nothing, while the dash lights still work.
- Why it happens
- The starter motor fails on these years, and corroded starter wiring or ground straps can cause the same symptom. German breakdown data flags starters on 2008-2010 cars.
- What to do
- Have the battery, starter wiring and ground strap checked before replacing the starter.
Alternator failure or overcharging
- What you'll notice
- The battery light comes on, lights dim or flicker, or the car stalls and won't restart because the battery goes flat.
- Why it happens
- The alternator can fail or overcharge, and some replacement parts have been hard to find.
- What to do
- Have the charging system tested. Replace the alternator if its output is too low or too high.
A/C leaks that are hard to find
- What you'll notice
- The A/C blows warm and needs recharging again and again.
- Why it happens
- Refrigerant leaks are common and can be hard to pin down; compressors and condensers have also failed on some cars.
- What to do
- Have the system leak-tested with dye or a sniffer before paying for another recharge.
ABS warning light from a failed wheel speed sensor
- What you'll notice
- The ABS and traction warning lights come on. The regular brakes still work.
- Why it happens
- A wheel speed sensor fails or its wiring is damaged, so the anti-lock system shuts off.
- What to do
- Have the ABS codes read to find which wheel's sensor failed. Brake with extra care on slippery roads until it is fixed.
Airbag light from seat or seatbelt sensor faults
- What you'll notice
- The airbag warning light stays on, or the passenger airbag off light behaves oddly.
- Why it happens
- Loose connectors at the seat weight sensor and failed seatbelt tensioners or sensors have triggered airbag faults on these cars.
- What to do
- Have the airbag codes read soon. The airbags may not work correctly while the light is on.
Gear selector sticks in Park or won't shift
- What you'll notice
- The shift lever is stiff, stuck in Park, the shift button jams, or the car won't leave Park even with the brake pressed.
- Why it happens
- The shifter mechanism can stick from dirt or lack of grease, and a faulty brake light switch can stop the car from letting you shift out of Park.
- What to do
- Check that the brake lights work. A shop can often clean and lubricate the shifter; a worn shifter or brake switch can be replaced.
Heater and A/C fan stops working
- What you'll notice
- No air from the vents on some or all fan speeds, or the fan works only now and then.
- Why it happens
- The HVAC blower motor wears out; its brushes can fail. It is the most common repair in TrueDelta's survey of fortwo owners.
- What to do
- Have the blower motor and its resistor and wiring tested. Replacing the motor usually fixes it.
Weak 12V battery causing odd warnings or no start
- What you'll notice
- Slow cranking or a dead car, sometimes with a check engine light or a rough-running engine before it fails.
- Why it happens
- The 12V battery in these small cars wears out, and a weak one can cause strange warning lights. Electric versions also rely on a 12V battery, which smart says to replace about every three years.
- What to do
- Have the battery tested first when odd warnings appear. Replace it with the correct type if it is weak.
Exhaust flex pipe or muffler failure
- What you'll notice
- A louder exhaust, rattling or buzzing from under the back of the car, or an exhaust smell.
- Why it happens
- The flex pipe, middle pipe and muffler crack or rust through; it is one of the more common repairs in owner surveys, and later cars also show early rust on the tailpipe and heat shields.
- What to do
- Have the exhaust inspected for leaks. Fix leaks soon so fumes don't get into the cabin.
Check engine light from secondary air injection pump
- What you'll notice
- The check engine light comes on, sometimes with a whirring noise right after a cold start.
- Why it happens
- The secondary air pump, which blows air into the exhaust on cold starts to cut emissions, can fail.
- What to do
- Have the code read. The car usually runs fine, but it needs fixing to pass an emissions test.
Squealing drive belt
- What you'll notice
- A squeal or whine from the engine, often at startup and especially on cars with the auto start-stop system.
- Why it happens
- The accessory drive belt or its tensioner wears. German breakdown data reports belt failures on many years of this generation.
- What to do
- Have the belt and tensioner checked and replaced if worn. A broken belt stops the alternator from charging.
Engine oil leaks on older cars
- What you'll notice
- Oil spots under the rear of the car or an oil smell, often found at inspection.
- Why it happens
- Seals and gaskets on older 1.0L engines start to leak with age.
- What to do
- Check the oil level often and have the source of the leak found. These engines have a small oil capacity, so running low happens quickly.
Headlight bulbs burning out often
- What you'll notice
- One headlight goes out, sometimes the same side again and again.
- Why it happens
- Owners in TrueDelta's survey report frequent headlight bulb replacements on these cars.
- What to do
- Replace the bulb with the correct type. If the same one keeps failing, have the connector and wiring checked.
Tire pressure warning from failed TPMS sensors
- What you'll notice
- The tire pressure light stays on even though the tires are inflated correctly.
- Why it happens
- A tire pressure sensor or its valve stem fails; valve stems show up often in owner repair reports.
- What to do
- Check all tires with a gauge first. A tire shop can find and replace the bad sensor.
Repair prices for your 2008 smart fortwo
Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.
- Replace clutch actuator
- Transmission software update and shifter/clutch relearn
- Replace clutch plate
- Clean and lubricate or replace shifter assembly
- Seal water leak and repair or replace water-damaged actuator
- Replace ignition coil(s)
- Replace HVAC blower motor
- Replace starter
- Replace alternator
- Replace 12V battery
- Replace rear muffler assembly (or weld/replace the flex pipe)
- Replace drive belt (and tensioner if worn)
- Engine oil leak inspection (repair extra)
- A/C leak test and recharge (or condenser/compressor)
- Replace headlight bulb
- Replace wheel speed sensor
- Replace tire pressure sensor
- Repair connector or replace seat/seatbelt sensor
Recall repairs: usually free at the dealer
A dealer can confirm coverage by VIN. An eligible safety recall repair is provided at no charge.
- Replace engine compartment insulation matNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Repaint windshield/roof bonding areaNo charge if your vehicle is included
Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.
Checking the NHTSA recall database…