Your 2012 Tesla Model Sproblems, repair costs and recalls
What we've documented about the 2012 Tesla Model S: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.
Ownership snapshot
Averages, not quotesRoutine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.
Known problems for your 2012 Tesla Model S
19 documented issues apply to 2012, most serious first.
Drive unit grinding or milling noise
- What you'll notice
- A grinding, milling or droning sound from the rear that rises and falls with speed, most noticeable when speeding up or slowing down. Some cars also clunk when shifting between drive and reverse.
- Why it happens
- Early Model S drive units (the motor, inverter and gearbox in one housing) often developed noise. Some cases were a loose cable or a differential that needed a shim; others needed a full replacement unit.
- What to do
- Have Tesla or an EV specialist listen to it and read the drive unit data. A noise alone is not an emergency, but a unit that loses power or throws an error should be repaired before long trips.
Touchscreen goes blank from worn memory chip (recall 21V-035)
- What you'll notice
- The center screen reboots, goes black or freezes. You may lose the backup camera, defrost and defog controls, and some warning chimes.
- Why it happens
- The 8 GB flash memory chip inside the media control unit (MCU1) wears out from constant writing. Once it is full of worn blocks the computer can't start properly.
- What to do
- Check your VIN for the recall. Tesla replaces the memory board for free under it; if the screen is already failing, avoid driving where you'd need the defroster.
Free under the recall. Ask Tesla service to check your VIN for open recalls.
Onboard charger stops charging
- What you'll notice
- The car won't charge from a home or destination charger, charges at a fraction of the usual speed, or shows a charging error. Supercharging may still work.
- Why it happens
- The onboard charger that converts household AC power to DC for the battery fails, or one of its internal modules does.
- What to do
- Try a different charger and cable first to rule them out. If AC charging still fails, the onboard charger needs diagnosis; DC fast charging can get you by in the meantime.
Air suspension sags or fails
- What you'll notice
- One corner or the rear sits low after parking, the compressor runs often or loudly, the body leans more in turns, or a suspension warning appears.
- Why it happens
- The air springs in the struts crack and leak with age, which overworks the compressor until it fails. Control module faults can also disable the system.
- What to do
- Check if the car sits level each morning. Get a leak test before the compressor burns out, and don't drive far on a fully deflated corner. Coil-spring conversion kits exist for 2012–2016 cars.
Power steering bolts can corrode and break (recall 18V-204)
- What you'll notice
- Steering suddenly becomes much heavier, especially at low speed, or you hear a clunk from the steering rack.
- Why it happens
- Aluminum bolts holding the power steering motor can corrode, mostly in cold, salted-road areas, and snap, which cuts power assist.
- What to do
- Check your VIN for the recall; Tesla replaces the bolts for free. If steering gets heavy, slow down and drive carefully to a service center.
Free under the recall. Ask Tesla service to check your VIN for open recalls.
Passenger airbag inflator can rupture (recalls 17V-023, 18V-031, 19V-002)
- What you'll notice
- No warning before a crash. The risk is only that metal fragments could hit people if the airbag deploys.
- Why it happens
- These cars use Takata passenger airbag inflators that can break apart with age, heat and humidity.
- What to do
- Check your VIN now and get the free replacement right away.
Free under the recall. Ask Tesla service to check your VIN for open recalls.
Front seat belt may not be connected to pretensioner (recall 15V-780)
- What you'll notice
- No symptom you can see in normal driving.
- Why it happens
- Front seat belts may not have been attached properly to the outboard lap pretensioner and could come loose in a crash.
- What to do
- Check your VIN for the recall and have the belt connection inspected for free.
Free under the recall. Ask Tesla service to check your VIN for open recalls.
Door handles won't extend or open the door
- What you'll notice
- The flush door handle doesn't pop out when you walk up or press it, or it extends but the door won't unlatch. You may have to get in through another door.
- Why it happens
- The motorized handles use a small gear, motor, microswitches and a thin wiring harness inside each handle. The gear cracks and the wires or switches break from repeated movement.
- What to do
- Report it before it gets worse; the handle usually fails on one door at a time. Independent shops and rebuild kits can repair the handle for much less than a new assembly.
Yellow border or bubbles on the screens
- What you'll notice
- A yellow or dark band creeps in from the edges of the center screen, bubbles appear under the glass, or a sticky liquid seeps out. The instrument cluster can do the same.
- Why it happens
- The adhesive between the display layers breaks down with heat and age.
- What to do
- This is cosmetic at first, but the screen can become hard to read. Ask about a display replacement or an upgrade to the newer MCU2 computer, which owners often choose at the same time.
Battery coolant heater fails
- What you'll notice
- An alert that the battery can't be heated, slow charging or limited regenerative braking in cold weather, and sometimes a no-charge condition.
- Why it happens
- The electric heater that warms the battery coolant on early cars fails, so the pack can't be warmed up in the cold.
- What to do
- Have Tesla or an EV shop confirm the fault code. Park in a garage in winter until it is repaired, since a cold pack charges slowly.
Front control arms and links clunk
- What you'll notice
- Clunks, creaks or knocks from the front over bumps, a loose feel, or uneven tire wear.
- Why it happens
- The bushings and ball joints in the front upper and lower control arms and the rear trailing and sway-bar links wear early on this heavy car.
- What to do
- Have the suspension inspected and replace worn arms in pairs, followed by an alignment to protect the tires.
12-volt battery dies early
- What you'll notice
- Warnings to replace the 12-volt battery soon, the car not waking up or unlocking, or a black screen and a car that won't go into drive.
- Why it happens
- The small 12-volt battery that runs the computers and locks wears out every few years, sometimes much sooner. It is one of the most reported Model S repairs.
- What to do
- Replace it as soon as the warning appears. If the car is dead, a jump to the 12-volt terminals behind the front trunk will usually wake it up.
Parking brake caliper seizes
- What you'll notice
- The parking brake won't release, a rear wheel drags or gets hot, or the parking brake light comes on.
- Why it happens
- The small electric parking brake calipers on the rear wheels corrode and stick, especially in salted-road areas.
- What to do
- Don't drive with a dragging brake. Have the rear calipers serviced, and in winter climates have the brakes cleaned and lubricated yearly.
Panoramic roof leaks or rattles
- What you'll notice
- Water drips at the C-pillars, into the rear hatch or onto the headliner after rain or washing; the sunroof may stick, sit crooked or make noise.
- Why it happens
- Roof seals shrink or shift and drain paths clog. The sliding panoramic roof can also go out of alignment.
- What to do
- Keep the drains clear and have the seals inspected as soon as you see water. Dry out wet carpets fast to protect wiring.
Charge port door or latch faults
- What you'll notice
- The charge port door won't open or close, the cable won't lock in or release, or charging stops partway.
- Why it happens
- The small motor, sensor or wiring for the charge port door and latch fails or corrodes.
- What to do
- Try the manual release inside the trunk if the cable is stuck. Have the port motor, sensor and wiring checked.
Autosteer may not keep the driver engaged (recall 23V-838)
- What you'll notice
- Autosteer can stay on even if you look away or don't hold the wheel enough.
- Why it happens
- Driver monitoring checks were judged too weak to prevent misuse of Autosteer.
- What to do
- Install the over-the-air update, and always keep hands on the wheel and eyes on the road when using Autopilot.
Free under the recall. Ask Tesla service to check your VIN for open recalls.
Wind noise from doors and windows
- What you'll notice
- Whistling or roaring at highway speed from a front door or window, or doors that need extra force to close.
- Why it happens
- The frameless door glass and seals drift out of alignment, and some doors sag over time.
- What to do
- Ask for a window recalibration and seal adjustment first. A sagging door needs a body shop to realign it.
Headlight LED or daytime light failure
- What you'll notice
- Part of a headlight goes dark, such as the LED running light strip, or a warning about a lamp appears.
- Why it happens
- The LEDs and their circuit boards inside the sealed headlight fail and can't be replaced separately.
- What to do
- Ask whether a repaired or used assembly is available, since a new headlight is expensive.
Tire pressure monitor errors
- What you'll notice
- A tire pressure warning or system error even though the tires are fine, or no pressure readings.
- Why it happens
- Early tire pressure sensors and their receiver fail or stop talking to the car.
- What to do
- Check pressures with a gauge. Replacing a single sensor is cheap; several owners upgraded to newer sensors and a new receiver.
Repair prices for your 2012 Tesla Model S
Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.
- Replace drive unit with a remanufactured unit
- Repair or replace one door handle assembly
- Replace center display or upgrade to MCU2
- Replace battery coolant heater
- Replace onboard charger
- Replace one air strut (with compressor if failed)
- Replace worn control arms and align
- Replace 12-volt battery
- Replace parking brake caliper
- Adjust door and window alignment, replace seals
- Repair charge port door motor, sensor or wiring
- Replace headlight assembly
- Replace tire pressure sensor or upgrade the system
Recall repairs: usually free at the dealer
A dealer can confirm coverage by VIN. An eligible safety recall repair is provided at no charge.
- Recall repair or software update at TeslaNo charge if your vehicle is included
Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.
Checking the NHTSA recall database…