Home › BMW › X1 › 2017
My vehicle

Your 2017 BMW X1problems, repair costs and recalls

What we've documented about the 2017 BMW X1: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.

Ownership snapshot

Averages, not quotes
Problems documented for 2017114 rated serious
Safety recalls…Checking NHTSA

Routine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)

Synthetic oil and filter change (BMW Longlife-approved oil)Every 5,000–10,000 miles or once a year · Many owners change oil more often than BMW's long condition-based interval.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Front brake pads, rotors and wear sensorAbout every 20,000–40,000 miles · X1 owners report faster-than-average brake wear.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Rear brake pads, rotors and wear sensorAbout every 25,000–50,000 miles · The electronic parking brake must be put in service mode with a scan tool.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
12-volt AGM battery replacement and registrationAbout every 4–6 years · The new battery must be registered to the car with a scan tool.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Spark plug replacement (4-cylinder)About every 45,000–60,000 miles · The 2013-2015 xDrive35i six-cylinder needs six plugs.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Engine coolant drain and refillAround 100,000 miles or every 4–6 years · Needs a bleed or vacuum fill to remove air pockets.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate

The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.

Known problems for your 2017 BMW X1

11 documented issues apply to 2017, most serious first.

Stop soon2013–2022Cooling

Coolant leaks and electric water pump failure

What you'll notice
Low coolant warnings, puddles or a sweet smell under the hood, the temperature gauge climbing, or a sudden overheating warning with reduced power.
Why it happens
Many cooling parts are plastic: the water pump housing, thermostat housing, expansion tank, hoses and radiator ends. They crack with age and heat. The electric water pump can also quit with little warning.
What to do
If the overheating warning comes on, pull over and shut the engine off. Have the cooling system pressure-tested to find the leak; replacing the failed part early avoids head gasket damage.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace electric water pump and thermostat. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Stop soon2016–2017Safety

Passenger airbag may be blocked by the dashboard (recall)

What you'll notice
No symptoms before a crash.
Why it happens
The instrument panel may stop the front passenger airbag from opening the way it should.
What to do
Check your VIN for recall 17V-062 and get the free dealer repair.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Free under recall 17V-062.
Stop soon2016–2017Safety

Driver seat belt may not lock (recall)

What you'll notice
No obvious symptom in daily driving.
Why it happens
The locking mechanism in the driver's seat belt retractor may not lock as designed in a crash or hard stop.
What to do
Check your VIN for recall 16V-747 and have the free repair done.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Free under recall 16V-747.
Stop soon2017Safety

Seat side airbags may not deploy (recall)

What you'll notice
Usually no symptom; an airbag warning light may come on.
Why it happens
The igniters for the seat-mounted side airbags may fail to fire, so the side airbag would not inflate in a crash.
What to do
Check your VIN for recall 16V-914 and have the free repair done.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Free under recall 16V-914.
Get checked2013–2022Engine2.0L turbo 4-cylinder and 3.0L turbo 6-cylinder

Oil leaks from the valve cover and oil filter housing

What you'll notice
Burning oil smell, light smoke from the engine bay, oil spots under the car, or the oil level dropping between changes.
Why it happens
The plastic valve cover and its rubber gasket, and the oil filter housing gasket, harden and crack from years of heat cycles. Oil then drips onto the hot exhaust. Newer engines have fewer reports, but filter housing and crankcase vent leaks still show up.
What to do
Have the leak traced to its source. Fix it soon, since oil on the exhaust is a fire risk and oil on belts and engine mounts damages them.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace valve cover with gasket or oil filter housing gasket. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Engine oil leak →
Get checked2016–2022Engine

Cracked engine mounts

What you'll notice
Clunking or thumping from the front when shifting or pulling away, extra vibration at idle, and the engine shaking more than it should.
Why it happens
The engine mounts, usually the upper passenger-side mount first, crack or wear out. Some fail before 20,000 miles; most go by around 100,000.
What to do
Have the mounts inspected if the car shakes or clunks. A failed mount is not an emergency, but leaving it lets the engine move and strains hoses and other mounts.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace upper engine mount(s). Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2016–2018Engine

Rough idle or stalling after a cold start

What you'll notice
The engine idles roughly or the rpm bounces after a cold start. It may sputter, shake or stall when you shift into gear.
Why it happens
An engine software issue on early second-generation cars. BMW released a bulletin in late 2017 with an engine computer software update.
What to do
Ask the dealer to check whether the latest engine software is installed. Letting the engine idle a little longer before shifting is a short-term workaround.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Engine computer software update. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Car starts then dies →
Get checked2016–2017Suspension

Front control arm clunk over bumps

What you'll notice
A clunk or crunching noise from the front, often the passenger side, when going over speed bumps or potholes.
Why it happens
The front lower control arms (wishbones) on early cars can develop play. BMW issued a 2016 bulletin to replace both with an updated part.
What to do
Have the front suspension checked and ask the dealer about the bulletin and updated control arms.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace both front lower control arms with updated parts. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Clunk over bumps →
Get checked2016–2022Transmission

Transmission message asks you to use the parking brake

What you'll notice
A random warning when parking says to secure the car with the parking brake and see a service center. The car may not seem to go into Park properly.
Why it happens
A small spring in the gear selector's shift-lock solenoid does not engage reliably, so the car cannot confirm it is in Park.
What to do
Always set the parking brake until it is fixed. Ask a shop whether the selector spring can be repaired before paying for a whole new gear selector.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Repair or replace gear selector assembly. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2016–2019Body

B-pillar trim may not cushion a head impact (recall)

What you'll notice
No symptoms in daily driving.
Why it happens
The upper trim on the pillar between the front and rear doors may not absorb enough energy if an occupant's head hits it in a crash.
What to do
Check your VIN for recall 19V-349 and have the free trim replacement done.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Free under recall 19V-349.
Monitor2013–2022Brakes

Brake pads and rotors wear out quickly

What you'll notice
Brake wear warnings or squealing as soon as about 20,000 miles, and frequent pad changes front and rear.
Why it happens
Pad compounds chosen for strong braking, plus the stability control system applying the brakes, wear pads and rotors faster than on many other small SUVs.
What to do
Budget for brake service more often than usual. Rear pad changes need a scan tool to retract the electronic parking brake.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Front brake pads, rotors and wear sensor. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Repair animation · Brake Pads
Price guide

Repair prices for your 2017 BMW X1

Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.

  • Replace electric water pump and thermostat
  • Replace valve cover with gasket or oil filter housing gasket
  • Replace upper engine mount(s)
  • Engine computer software update
  • Replace both front lower control arms with updated parts
  • Repair or replace gear selector assembly
  • Front brake pads, rotors and wear sensor

Recall repairs: usually free at the dealer

A dealer can confirm coverage by VIN. An eligible safety recall repair is provided at no charge.

  • Dealer recall repairNo charge if your vehicle is included
Get help with a shop quote →

Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.

Safety recalls for the 2017 BMW X1
Checking the NHTSA recall database…
Keep a copy of this pageDownload the snapshot, every problem, the repair costs and the recalls for your 2017 BMW X1 as a PDF you can save, print or bring to your shop.
This page is a general guide based on widely reported problems. Not every vehicle is affected, and it doesn't replace an in-person diagnosis.