Your 2009 Subaru Legacyproblems, repair costs and recalls
What we've documented about the 2009 Subaru Legacy: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.
Pick your engine to hide problems that only affect other engines. Not sure? It is on the sticker under the hood or in the owner's manual.
Ownership snapshot
Averages, not quotesRoutine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.
Known problems for your 2009 Subaru Legacy
6 documented issues apply to 2009, most serious first.
Head gasket leaks
- What you'll notice
- Oil or coolant seeping from where the cylinder heads meet the engine block, a sweet coolant smell, the coolant level dropping, the temperature gauge rising, or a rough idle with misfire codes.
- Why it happens
- The 2.5L four-cylinder of these years used head gaskets that break down with age. On the 1996-1999 engine they tend to fail inside and cause overheating; on 2000 and later engines they usually start as slow outside leaks of oil and coolant.
- What to do
- Check coolant and oil levels often and watch the temperature gauge. If it starts to overheat, pull over and shut it off. Get a cooling system pressure test, and plan the repair before a small leak becomes an overheated engine.
Turbocharger failure from oil starvation
- What you'll notice
- Whining or siren noise from the engine, blue smoke from the exhaust, loss of boost and power, or a check engine light with codes P0011 or P0021.
- Why it happens
- The turbo on the GT is fed oil through a bolt with a fine filter screen that can clog with sludge. Starved of oil, the turbo bearings wear out. Late or skipped oil changes make it far more likely.
- What to do
- Use the correct full-synthetic oil and change it on time. If you get P0011/P0021 codes, have the oil feed screens checked right away; they are an early warning. A smoking turbo needs to be replaced before it damages the engine.
Takata passenger airbag inflator (recall)
- What you'll notice
- There is usually no warning. The danger only shows up in a crash, when the passenger airbag deploys.
- Why it happens
- The Takata inflator can break down after years of heat and humidity and burst when the airbag fires, throwing metal pieces into the cabin. Some earlier replacement inflators were also recalled.
- What to do
- Ask a Subaru dealer to check your VIN for open recalls today. If the recall is open, contact a Subaru dealer right away; the repair is free.
Free under the Takata recalls (such as 15V-323 and 18V-012). Check the VIN first.
Brake lines can rust through (recall)
- What you'll notice
- A soft or sinking brake pedal, brake fluid under the car, or the brake warning light.
- Why it happens
- In salt-belt states, salty water can splash past the fuel tank guard and rust the brake lines until they leak, which makes the car take longer to stop.
- What to do
- If the pedal feels soft, get the car checked before driving it more. Check your VIN; dealers inspect, coat and replace leaking lines for free.
Free under recalls 13V-110 and 14V-311. Check the VIN first.
Secondary air pump relay can stick on (recall)
- What you'll notice
- A whirring pump that keeps running and a burning plastic smell from the engine bay.
- Why it happens
- The relay for the emissions air pump can fail closed, so the pump runs all the time, overheats and can melt, which is a fire risk.
- What to do
- If you smell burning plastic, shut the car off and park it outside. Check your VIN; dealers replace the relay for free.
Free under recall 16V-738. Check the VIN first.
Ignition switch can shut the engine off (recall)
- What you'll notice
- The engine can switch off while driving, with loss of power steering and brake assist.
- Why it happens
- A spring inside the ignition switch can break, letting the switch move out of the run position.
- What to do
- Check your VIN. Keep heavy key rings off the key until it is fixed. The dealer repair is free.
Free under recall 19V-297. Check the VIN first.
Repair prices for your 2009 Subaru Legacy
Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.
- Replace both head gaskets and resurface heads
- Replace turbocharger and oil feed line
Recall repairs: usually free at the dealer
A dealer can confirm coverage by VIN. An eligible safety recall repair is provided at no charge.
- Replace passenger airbag inflatorNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Replace rusted brake lines and bleed brakesNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Replace secondary air pump relayNo charge if your vehicle is included
- Replace ignition switchNo charge if your vehicle is included
Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.
Checking the NHTSA recall database…