Your 2004 Toyota MR2 Spyderproblems, repair costs and recalls
What we've documented about the 2004 Toyota MR2 Spyder: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.
Ownership snapshot
Averages, not quotesRoutine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.
Known problems for your 2004 Toyota MR2 Spyder
14 documented issues apply to 2004, most serious first.
Heavy oil consumption
- What you'll notice
- You need to add oil between changes, see blue-gray smoke, or find the dipstick low. Running low can lead to knocking and engine failure.
- Why it happens
- Early 1.8L engines can let oil slip past the piston rings and burn it. Toyota changed the rings and pistons during 2001 and 2002 production, so the earliest cars are worst, but high-mileage later cars can still burn oil.
- What to do
- Check the oil level every fill-up and keep it full. If it uses more than about a quart every 1,000-1,500 miles, have a compression and leak-down test done and the pre-cats inspected. If it knocks or the oil light comes on, stop and shut the engine off.
SMT stalls, lurches or misshifts
- What you'll notice
- The car lurches, picks the wrong gear, shifts by itself, or stalls at low speed with the gear warning light on.
- Why it happens
- The SMT relies on an electronic control unit, a hydraulic pump, hydraulic lines and clutch and gear actuators. Owners report pump and actuator failures, and one reported a corroded hydraulic line that made the car lurch forward. Repairs are often costly.
- What to do
- Avoid traffic and highways if it misshifts or stalls, since it can lose drive suddenly. Have the codes read by a shop that knows the SMT; sometimes a used transmission costs less than repairing the parts.
SMT warning light, buzzing, or gears won't change
- What you'll notice
- On cars with the clutchless sequential manual (SMT), the SMT warning light comes on, you hear a buzzing from the engine compartment, or the car won't change gears.
- Why it happens
- Fluid can seep from the SMT hydraulic unit at the reservoir cap or its seals, so the pump runs longer and pressure drops. Toyota bulletin T-SB-0031-18 replaces two seal rings, then refills and bleeds the fluid.
- What to do
- If the car won't shift, park it safely and have it towed. Ask a Toyota dealer or SMT-savvy shop to read the codes and check bulletin T-SB-0031-18 before replacing major parts.
Timing chain wear or variable valve timing fault (P1349)
- What you'll notice
- The check engine light comes on with code P1349, the engine idles rough or feels weak, or you hear a rattle from the timing chain.
- Why it happens
- The timing chain, its sprockets and the VVT-i gear can wear, especially when oil changes are skipped or the oil runs low. Toyota issued a bulletin for the P1349 code on these engines.
- What to do
- Check the oil level first. Have the oil control valve, its screen and the timing chain checked; catching chain wear early avoids engine damage.
Manual transmission slips out of gear or shifter feels loose
- What you'll notice
- The car pops out of gear while driving, or the shifter feels sloppy and hard to place in gear.
- Why it happens
- Owners report gears slipping out on the 5-speed manual. Toyota also ran a service campaign on early cars to re-tighten loose shift control bracket bolts, and issued a bulletin on the shift cable bracket.
- What to do
- Have the shift cables, bracket and mounts checked. If it keeps popping out of gear, hold the lever only as long as needed to get it inspected; worn internal parts need a transmission repair.
Worn, torn or broken convertible top
- What you'll notice
- Rain gets in around or through the soft top, the fabric is split or frayed, or the rear window is cracked or loose from the top.
- Why it happens
- The soft top fabric and its sewn-in rear window wear with age, sun and folding. Because the rear glass is part of the top, damage to the window usually means replacing the whole top.
- What to do
- Keep water out with a temporary cover and dry the interior. Get quotes for a replacement top; many owners buy an aftermarket top and have an upholstery shop fit it.
Water inside from clogged convertible top drains
- What you'll notice
- Wet carpet, a damp or musty smell, or water pooling behind the seats after rain or a car wash.
- Why it happens
- Rain off the soft top runs out through small one-way drain valves behind the side air scoops. They clog with dirt and leaves, and trapped water can rust the floor over time.
- What to do
- Have the side scoop trims removed and the drains cleaned. Dry the carpet fully and look for rust underneath.
Parking brake cable or rear caliper sticking
- What you'll notice
- The parking brake won't release fully, a rear wheel drags or gets hot, or the parking brake doesn't hold well.
- Why it happens
- The parking brake cables and rear calipers corrode and seize, especially on cars that sit or see road salt.
- What to do
- If a wheel is hot or the car pulls, have the brakes checked soon. Seized cables and calipers are usually replaced.
Oxygen sensor failure
- What you'll notice
- The check engine light is on, fuel economy drops, or the car fails an emissions test.
- Why it happens
- The MR2 Spyder has three oxygen sensors. The one after the main catalytic converter fails most often.
- What to do
- Have the codes read to see which sensor is at fault. It is not urgent, but fix it before inspection and check oil use too, since oil burning can foul sensors.
Rattle from loose exhaust heat shields
- What you'll notice
- A tinny rattle from behind the seats or under the car, often at certain engine speeds.
- Why it happens
- Exhaust heat shields loosen or rust around their fasteners. Owners also report engine rattles at all speeds, which need checking because pre-cat or timing chain trouble can sound similar.
- What to do
- Have a shop find the source. A loose shield is cheap to clamp, but rule out the pre-cats and timing chain first.
Check engine light and lean running in freezing weather
- What you'll notice
- In below-freezing weather, the check engine light comes on with lean, misfire or oxygen sensor codes (P0171, P030x, P0133).
- Why it happens
- Toyota found these engines could run lean in subfreezing temperatures and issued a bulletin with a fix.
- What to do
- Have the codes read. If they match and it happens in cold weather, ask a Toyota dealer about bulletin 04707.
Brake groan or squeak
- What you'll notice
- A groan or squeak from the brakes when slowing down.
- Why it happens
- Toyota issued a tech tip about certain brake pads causing groan or squeak noises.
- What to do
- Have the pads and rotors checked. If they are in good shape, ask about the updated pads in the tech tip.
Hard starting or rough idle after the battery is disconnected
- What you'll notice
- After a battery change or dead battery, the engine is hard to start or idles low and rough.
- Why it happens
- The engine computer loses its learned idle settings when power is cut. Toyota issued a tech tip on relearning them.
- What to do
- Let the engine idle until fully warm with accessories off. If it does not settle, a shop can run the idle relearn.
Crankshaft sensor code (P0335) from a weak battery
- What you'll notice
- The check engine light comes on with code P0335, sometimes after slow cranking.
- Why it happens
- Toyota found that low battery voltage while cranking can set this crankshaft sensor code even when the sensor is fine.
- What to do
- Have the battery and charging system tested before replacing the sensor.
Repair prices for your 2004 Toyota MR2 Spyder
Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.
- Replace short block (engine) or install a used engine
- Repair SMT hydraulic line, pump or actuator, or replace SMT control unit
- Replace SMT reservoir seal rings, refill and bleed fluid (T-SB-0031-18)
- Replace VVT oil control valve (timing chain tensioner if worn)
- Inspect shift linkage and re-torque shift bracket bolts
- Replace soft top with glass rear window
- Clear top drain valves and dry carpet
- Replace parking brake cable
- Replace oxygen sensor
- Diagnose noise and clamp or refasten heat shield
- Diagnose lean codes and perform bulletin repair
- Replace front or rear brake pads
- Idle relearn and throttle body cleaning
- Test and replace 12V battery
Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.
Checking the NHTSA recall database…