Home › BMW › 1 / 2 Series › 2009
My vehicle

Your 2009 BMW 1 / 2 Seriesproblems, repair costs and recalls

What we've documented about the 2009 BMW 1 / 2 Series: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.

Pick your engine to hide problems that only affect other engines. Not sure? It is on the sticker under the hood or in the owner's manual.

Ownership snapshot

Averages, not quotes
Problems documented for 2009179 rated serious
Safety recalls…Checking NHTSA

Routine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)

Synthetic oil and filter change (BMW Longlife-approved oil)Every 5,000–7,500 miles or once a year · Many specialists advise shorter intervals than BMW's 10,000-15,000 miles on turbo engines.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Front brake pads, rotors and wear sensorAbout every 25,000–40,000 miles · M models with larger brakes cost more.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Rear brake pads, rotors and wear sensorAbout every 30,000–50,000 miles
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
12-volt AGM battery replacement and registrationAbout every 4–6 years · The new battery must be registered to the car with a scan tool.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Spark plug replacementAbout every 40,000–60,000 miles (sooner on turbo engines)
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Engine coolant drain and refillAround 100,000 miles or every 4–6 years
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate

The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.

Known problems for your 2009 BMW 1 / 2 Series

17 documented issues apply to 2009, most serious first.

Stop soon2008–2018Engine3.0L inline-6, 3.0L turbo inline-6 and 2.0L turbo 4-cylinder (2008-2018)

Oil filter housing gasket leak

What you'll notice
Oil dripping under the front of the car, a burning oil smell, or oil coating the front of the engine and the drive belt area.
Why it happens
The rubber gasket under the oil filter housing hardens with age and heat and starts to leak. Oil can soak the serpentine belt, which may slip off and get pulled into the front of the engine.
What to do
Have it fixed soon rather than just topping up oil. A shredded belt can damage the engine, so do not drive far if the belt area is soaked in oil.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace oil filter housing gasket (housing if cracked) and inspect drive belt. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Engine oil leak →
Stop soon2008–2021CoolingSix-cylinder engines and 2.0L turbo 4-cylinder (2008-2021, except 230i)

Electric water pump and thermostat failure

What you'll notice
An engine temperature warning, the radiator fan running at full speed, reduced power (limp mode), or a sudden overheat.
Why it happens
These engines use an electric coolant pump that tends to fail without warning, often around 60,000-80,000 miles. The thermostat often fails along with it.
What to do
Pull over and shut the engine off if it overheats. Have the pump and thermostat replaced together; many owners replace them before they fail on higher-mileage cars.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace electric water pump and thermostat. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Stop soon2008–2011Fuel3.0L twin-turbo inline-6 (135i, 1 Series M)

High-pressure fuel pump failure

What you'll notice
Long cranking before the engine starts, stuttering or power loss when accelerating, stalling, and a reduced-power warning.
Why it happens
The original high-pressure fuel pump on the N54 twin-turbo engine was not durable. BMW revised the pump and extended its coverage to 10 years or 120,000 miles.
What to do
Check whether the extended coverage still applies. If not, an updated pump fixes it; do not keep driving with severe hesitation.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace high-pressure fuel pump. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Stop soon2008–2011Fuel3.0L twin-turbo inline-6 (135i, 1 Series M)

Leaking fuel injectors cause misfires

What you'll notice
Misfires, a shaking engine, a flashing check engine light and loss of power.
Why it happens
The N54 piezo injectors fail or leak, and BMW went through many revisions of the part. Some cars had extended coverage on the injectors.
What to do
Have the misfiring cylinder identified. A leaking injector can wash oil off the cylinder walls, so fix it promptly and replace with the latest revision.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace fuel injector(s) with latest revision. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Engine sputters or misfires →
Stop soon2008–2013Safety

Driver airbag inflator can rupture (recalls)

What you'll notice
Usually no warning before a crash.
Why it happens
The driver frontal airbag inflator can build too much pressure and burst, throwing metal pieces into the cabin. Some interim replacement inflators were also recalled.
What to do
Check your VIN now and get the airbag replaced free at a BMW dealer.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Stop soon2008–2012Electrical

Blower motor wiring can overheat and start a fire (recall)

What you'll notice
A burning plastic smell from the dash or heater fan, or the fan stopping working, even with the car parked.
Why it happens
The wiring harness for the blower motor regulator can overheat and melt its connector.
What to do
Check your VIN. Dealers inspect and replace the harness for free; until then, report any burning smell right away.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Stop soon2008–2012Electrical

Battery cable connection can fail and cut power (recall)

What you'll notice
Sudden loss of electrical power, warning lights, stalling or a no-start.
Why it happens
The positive battery cable connector at the fuse box can degrade and lose contact.
What to do
Run a recall check. Dealers replace the connector and secure it with an improved design for free.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Stop soon2008–2013Engine3.0L inline-6 (128i)

PCV valve heater can short and catch fire (recall)

What you'll notice
Possible burning smell from the engine bay; often no warning.
Why it happens
The heater for the crankcase vent (PCV) valve can short circuit and overheat, with a fire risk even when the car is off.
What to do
Check your VIN; cars repaired under the earlier recalls must go back for the newer fix.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Stop soon2008–2011Safety

Seat belt pretensioner can ignite insulation (recall)

What you'll notice
No warning until a crash.
Why it happens
When the front belt pretensioners fire in a serious crash, nearby sound insulation could catch fire.
What to do
Check your VIN; dealers replace the retractors and/or modify the insulation for free.
Typical repair costNo charge if your vehicle is in the recall
Dealer recall repair
Get checked2008–2018Engine3.0L inline-6, 3.0L turbo inline-6 and 2.0L turbo 4-cylinder (2008-2018)

Valve cover gasket leak or cracked valve cover

What you'll notice
A burning oil smell (sometimes through the vents), light smoke from the engine bay, oil on the spark plugs, or a low oil warning.
Why it happens
The plastic valve cover can warp and crack and its rubber gasket hardens with heat cycles, letting oil seep onto the hot exhaust side of the engine.
What to do
Have a shop confirm the leak. Oil reaching the exhaust or turbo is a fire risk, so do not leave it for long.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace valve cover and gasket. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Engine oil leak →
Get checked2008–2025Cooling

Coolant leaks from plastic hoses and expansion tank

What you'll notice
A low coolant warning, a sweet smell, coolant drips, or overheating and limp mode in bad cases.
Why it happens
Many cooling-system parts are plastic and become brittle with age, so hoses, flanges, the coolant level sensor and the expansion tank start to leak. RepairPal lists coolant-related overheating as the most reported 228i problem.
What to do
Top up with BMW-approved coolant and have the system pressure-tested. Fix leaks early, because overheating can warp the cylinder head.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace leaking coolant hose or expansion tank and bleed system. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2008–2025Engine

VANOS solenoid faults

What you'll notice
Check engine light, rough idle, hesitation or loss of power, poorer fuel economy, and sometimes reduced-power mode.
Why it happens
The VANOS solenoids that control variable cam timing wear or clog and stop controlling oil flow properly, typically from about 70,000-100,000 miles.
What to do
Have the codes read. Cleaning or replacing the solenoids is usually all that is needed, not a full VANOS rebuild.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace VANOS solenoids. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2008–2011Engine3.0L twin-turbo inline-6 (135i, 1 Series M)

Turbo wastegate rattle

What you'll notice
A metallic rattle from the engine when you lift off the throttle, a boost-related code (30FF), and eventually low power.
Why it happens
The wastegate arms in the N54 turbos loosen with wear. BMW issued extended coverage of 8 years or 82,000 miles for this rattle.
What to do
A light rattle is not urgent, but have it checked if you lose power. The fix is replacing the turbos, which is a big job.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace turbochargers. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2008–2018EngineTurbocharged engines (2008-2018)

Charge pipe cracks and loses boost

What you'll notice
A loud pop followed by power loss, no boost, and engine or drivetrain warning lights.
Why it happens
The plastic pipe between the turbo and the throttle becomes brittle with heat and age and can split, especially on tuned cars.
What to do
The car will usually limp along with low power. Replace the pipe, ideally with a stronger aftermarket aluminum one.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace charge pipe. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2008–2018EngineTurbocharged engines (2008-2018)

Carbon buildup on intake valves

What you'll notice
Rough idle, hesitation, misfires under load, lower power and fuel economy.
Why it happens
With direct injection, fuel never washes the intake valves, so carbon deposits build up over time, often noticeable after about 40,000-60,000 miles.
What to do
Ask a shop to inspect the intake valves. Walnut-shell blasting cleans them and restores smooth running.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Walnut-shell blast intake valves. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2008–2016Engine3.0L inline-6 and 3.0L turbo inline-6 (2008-2016)

Misfires and rough idle from worn coils or plugs

What you'll notice
Rough idle, misfires, slow starts in cold weather and a lack of power, sometimes without a VANOS code.
Why it happens
Spark plugs and ignition coils wear out; turbo engines are harder on them. Coils fail at higher mileage.
What to do
Have the misfire codes read. Replace worn plugs and any failing coils; plugs on turbo engines need changing more often than on non-turbo engines.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace spark plugs and failed ignition coils. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Rough idle or shaking when stopped →
Monitor2008–2013Body

Window regulator failure

What you'll notice
A window that drops into the door, moves slowly or crookedly, or will not go up, often with a grinding noise.
Why it happens
The cables or plastic parts in the window regulator wear and break.
What to do
Avoid using the window until fixed. Replace the regulator (and the motor if it is also failing).
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace window regulator. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Windows, locks or radio stopped working →
Price guide

Repair prices for your 2009 BMW 1 / 2 Series

Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.

  • Replace oil filter housing gasket (housing if cracked) and inspect drive belt
  • Replace valve cover and gasket
  • Replace electric water pump and thermostat
  • Replace leaking coolant hose or expansion tank and bleed system
  • Replace VANOS solenoids
  • Replace high-pressure fuel pump
  • Replace fuel injector(s) with latest revision
  • Replace turbochargers
  • Replace charge pipe
  • Walnut-shell blast intake valves
  • Replace spark plugs and failed ignition coils
  • Replace window regulator

Recall repairs: usually free at the dealer

A dealer can confirm coverage by VIN. An eligible safety recall repair is provided at no charge.

  • Dealer recall repairNo charge if your vehicle is included
Get help with a shop quote →

Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.

Safety recalls for the 2009 BMW 1 / 2 Series
Checking the NHTSA recall database…
Keep a copy of this pageDownload the snapshot, every problem, the repair costs and the recalls for your 2009 BMW 1 / 2 Series as a PDF you can save, print or bring to your shop.
This page is a general guide based on widely reported problems. Not every vehicle is affected, and it doesn't replace an in-person diagnosis.