Your 2017 BMW 1 / 2 Seriesproblems, repair costs and recalls
What we've documented about the 2017 BMW 1 / 2 Series: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.
Pick your engine to hide problems that only affect other engines. Not sure? It is on the sticker under the hood or in the owner's manual.
Ownership snapshot
Averages, not quotesRoutine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
Ask for an estimate
The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.
Known problems for your 2017 BMW 1 / 2 Series
11 documented issues apply to 2017, most serious first.
Oil filter housing gasket leak
- What you'll notice
- Oil dripping under the front of the car, a burning oil smell, or oil coating the front of the engine and the drive belt area.
- Why it happens
- The rubber gasket under the oil filter housing hardens with age and heat and starts to leak. Oil can soak the serpentine belt, which may slip off and get pulled into the front of the engine.
- What to do
- Have it fixed soon rather than just topping up oil. A shredded belt can damage the engine, so do not drive far if the belt area is soaked in oil.
Electric water pump and thermostat failure
- What you'll notice
- An engine temperature warning, the radiator fan running at full speed, reduced power (limp mode), or a sudden overheat.
- Why it happens
- These engines use an electric coolant pump that tends to fail without warning, often around 60,000-80,000 miles. The thermostat often fails along with it.
- What to do
- Pull over and shut the engine off if it overheats. Have the pump and thermostat replaced together; many owners replace them before they fail on higher-mileage cars.
Valve cover gasket leak or cracked valve cover
- What you'll notice
- A burning oil smell (sometimes through the vents), light smoke from the engine bay, oil on the spark plugs, or a low oil warning.
- Why it happens
- The plastic valve cover can warp and crack and its rubber gasket hardens with heat cycles, letting oil seep onto the hot exhaust side of the engine.
- What to do
- Have a shop confirm the leak. Oil reaching the exhaust or turbo is a fire risk, so do not leave it for long.
Coolant leaks from plastic hoses and expansion tank
- What you'll notice
- A low coolant warning, a sweet smell, coolant drips, or overheating and limp mode in bad cases.
- Why it happens
- Many cooling-system parts are plastic and become brittle with age, so hoses, flanges, the coolant level sensor and the expansion tank start to leak. RepairPal lists coolant-related overheating as the most reported 228i problem.
- What to do
- Top up with BMW-approved coolant and have the system pressure-tested. Fix leaks early, because overheating can warp the cylinder head.
Oil seeping from valve cover or oil filter housing on newer engines
- What you'll notice
- Oil residue around the top of the engine, a burning smell after driving, or oil spots under the car.
- Why it happens
- The newer 4- and 6-cylinder engines can still leak at the valve cover gasket and oil filter housing gasket as they age, and the oil filter housing on the 4-cylinder can crack.
- What to do
- Have the source of the leak confirmed before replacing parts. These repairs are routine, but do not let oil drip onto the exhaust.
VANOS solenoid faults
- What you'll notice
- Check engine light, rough idle, hesitation or loss of power, poorer fuel economy, and sometimes reduced-power mode.
- Why it happens
- The VANOS solenoids that control variable cam timing wear or clog and stop controlling oil flow properly, typically from about 70,000-100,000 miles.
- What to do
- Have the codes read. Cleaning or replacing the solenoids is usually all that is needed, not a full VANOS rebuild.
Charge pipe cracks and loses boost
- What you'll notice
- A loud pop followed by power loss, no boost, and engine or drivetrain warning lights.
- Why it happens
- The plastic pipe between the turbo and the throttle becomes brittle with heat and age and can split, especially on tuned cars.
- What to do
- The car will usually limp along with low power. Replace the pipe, ideally with a stronger aftermarket aluminum one.
Carbon buildup on intake valves
- What you'll notice
- Rough idle, hesitation, misfires under load, lower power and fuel economy.
- Why it happens
- With direct injection, fuel never washes the intake valves, so carbon deposits build up over time, often noticeable after about 40,000-60,000 miles.
- What to do
- Ask a shop to inspect the intake valves. Walnut-shell blasting cleans them and restores smooth running.
PCV valve in valve cover fails
- What you'll notice
- Smoke from the exhaust at start-up, rising oil consumption, rough or uneven running, or a whistling noise.
- Why it happens
- The crankcase ventilation (PCV) diaphragm built into the valve cover of the 6-cylinder engine can tear, upsetting the air-fuel mixture and pulling oil into the intake.
- What to do
- Have it diagnosed; usually the valve cover with its built-in PCV valve is replaced.
Manual gearbox grinds on fast shifts
- What you'll notice
- Grinding when shifting from first to second at high rpm, notchy shifts, or the car popping out of gear.
- Why it happens
- A worn synchronizer in the 6-speed manual used in the M235i and M2. Fixing it requires taking the gearbox apart.
- What to do
- Shift more gently and have it checked under warranty if possible; dealers often replace the whole gearbox.
Moisture inside headlights or taillights
- What you'll notice
- Fogging or water droplets inside the headlight or taillight lenses that don't clear.
- Why it happens
- Water enters through a cracked housing or failed seal, or condensation builds up and does not vent.
- What to do
- Light condensation that clears is normal. Persistent water can kill bulbs and electronics, so have the housing replaced if it keeps happening.
Repair prices for your 2017 BMW 1 / 2 Series
Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.
- Replace oil filter housing gasket (housing if cracked) and inspect drive belt
- Replace valve cover and gasket
- Replace electric water pump and thermostat
- Replace leaking coolant hose or expansion tank and bleed system
- Replace valve cover gasket or oil filter housing gasket
- Replace VANOS solenoids
- Replace charge pipe
- Walnut-shell blast intake valves
- Replace valve cover with built-in PCV valve
- Rebuild or replace manual transmission
- Replace tail light or headlight assembly
Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.
Checking the NHTSA recall database…