Home › Subaru › Forester › 2004
My vehicle

Your 2004 Subaru Foresterproblems, repair costs and recalls

What we've documented about the 2004 Subaru Forester: problems owners and shops report, typical repair and upkeep costs, and safety recalls.

Pick your engine to hide problems that only affect other engines. Not sure? It is on the sticker under the hood or in the owner's manual.

Ownership snapshot

Averages, not quotes
Problems documented for 200473 rated serious
Safety recalls…Checking NHTSA

Routine maintenance costs (model-wide, not specific to one year or engine)

Synthetic oil and filter changeAbout every 6,000 miles or 6 months · 2011+ FB engines and turbo XT models need full synthetic (0W-20 on most).
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Front brake pads and rotorsAbout every 30,000–60,000 miles
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Rear brake pads and rotorsAbout every 40,000–70,000 miles
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Battery replacementAbout every 3–5 years · Models with auto start-stop need an AGM battery.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate
Engine coolant drain and refillNewer models: first at about 137,500 miles · Use Subaru Super Coolant or an equivalent blue long-life coolant; older models need it sooner.
Price not verified
Ask for an estimate

The problems here are the ones we've documented so far, not a complete list or a reliability rating. Ask your shop for a written total that covers the work on your engine and trim, including any diagnostic fees, taxes and shop supplies.

Known problems for your 2004 Subaru Forester

7 documented issues apply to 2004, most serious first.

Stop soon1998–2010Engine2.5L non-turbo EJ25

Head gasket leaks

What you'll notice
Coolant that keeps going down, a sweet smell after driving, the temperature gauge climbing, or oil and coolant seeping where the cylinder heads meet the engine block.
Why it happens
The non-turbo 2.5L boxer engine of this era is known for head gasket failure as it ages. Earlier engines tended to leak internally and overheat, while later ones more often seeped oil or coolant on the outside first.
What to do
Have a cooling system pressure test and inspection at the first sign of seepage or coolant loss. If the engine overheats, pull over and shut it off, because driving hot can warp the heads.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace both head gaskets and resurface heads. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Stop soon2003–2008Suspension

Front control arm brackets can rust and break

What you'll notice
Clunking from the front end, loose or wandering steering, or nothing at all until a bracket gives way.
Why it happens
In salt-belt states the brackets that hold the front lower control arms can corrode badly. Subaru recalled affected vehicles to inspect, rustproof or replace the arms.
What to do
Check your VIN for an open recall. If the front end clunks or the steering feels loose, have it inspected before driving further.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace front lower control arms per recall. Prepare an itemized shop request. A dealer can check your VIN for possible recall or extended-warranty coverage.
Stop soon2004–2013Engine2.5L turbo EJ255 (XT)

Turbocharger failure from oil starvation

What you'll notice
Blue smoke from the exhaust, a siren-like whine or loss of boost, and sometimes check engine codes for cam timing (P0011 or P0021).
Why it happens
A small filter screen in the banjo bolt that feeds oil to the turbo can clog with sludge, starving the turbo of oil. Skipped or late oil changes make it much more likely.
What to do
Stop driving hard and have it checked right away if you see smoke or lose boost. A shop can inspect or replace the oil feed screen, and regular oil changes with the correct oil are the best prevention.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace turbocharger and oil feed line. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked1998–2008Drivetrain

AWD binding in tight turns (automatic)

What you'll notice
In slow, tight turns such as parking lots the car feels like it is braking itself, hops, or shudders, and it may get worse as the transmission warms up.
Why it happens
On automatic models the center clutch pack that splits power front to rear can stay locked up, often from a weak duty C solenoid, worn clutch plates, or mismatched tire sizes.
What to do
Make sure all four tires match in brand, size and wear, then have a Subaru-savvy shop check the transmission fluid and the AWD solenoid. Ongoing binding wears the drivetrain, so do not ignore it.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace AWD transfer (duty C) solenoid. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2003–2008Emissions

Catalytic converter failure (P0420)

What you'll notice
Check engine light with code P0420, a failed emissions test, or sometimes a rattle from under the car.
Why it happens
Owners of this generation frequently report worn-out catalytic converters, sometimes made worse by misfires or an engine burning oil or coolant.
What to do
Have the code confirmed and the oxygen sensors and engine checked for misfires or head gasket problems first, so a new converter is not ruined.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace front catalytic converter (Y-pipe). Prepare an itemized shop request.
Get checked2003–2008Suspension

Wheel bearing hum

What you'll notice
A humming or growling noise that rises with speed and may change when you steer left or right.
Why it happens
Owners of this generation commonly report worn wheel bearings, especially in the rear.
What to do
Have the bearings checked soon. A badly worn bearing can overheat and affect wheel stability.
Repair costInsufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair
Replace front wheel bearing. Prepare an itemized shop request.
Walk through this symptom: Humming noise at speed →
Monitor2003–2008Exhaust

Rattling exhaust heat shields

What you'll notice
A tinny buzz or rattle from under the car at certain engine speeds, often at idle or light acceleration.
Why it happens
The thin heat shields around the exhaust rust at their mounting points and come loose.
What to do
Have a shop secure the shield with a clamp or replace it. This is usually a quick, simple repair.
Price guide

Repair prices for your 2004 Subaru Forester

Insufficient verified pricing for this vehicle and repair. We have not yet matched these repairs to two independent, dated price sources for this vehicle, so we show no price, chart or verdict for them.

  • Replace both head gaskets and resurface heads
  • Replace AWD transfer (duty C) solenoid
  • Replace front lower control arms per recall
  • Replace front catalytic converter (Y-pipe)
  • Replace front wheel bearing
  • Replace turbocharger and oil feed line
Get help with a shop quote →

Disclaimer: Estimates only, not a quote. Ranges are averages built from typical parts prices plus standard book labor time at a typical shop labor rate. Your price will depend on your area, the shop, the parts used and what the shop finds. Dealers often charge more. Diagnosis and taxes are extra.

Safety recalls for the 2004 Subaru Forester
Checking the NHTSA recall database…
Keep a copy of this pageDownload the snapshot, every problem, the repair costs and the recalls for your 2004 Subaru Forester as a PDF you can save, print or bring to your shop.
This page is a general guide based on widely reported problems. Not every vehicle is affected, and it doesn't replace an in-person diagnosis.